Subscribe for More

While seemingly straightforward, choosing the right shipping partners requires careful analysis of service levels, costs, timeframes, and specialized capabilities to avoid delays, damages, and customer dissatisfaction.

Strategic carrier selection is a key differentiator in today’s competitive market. Customers demand fast, affordable, reliable shipping, so meeting these expectations is crucial for your brand reputation and profitability.

This guide covers everything from carrier types and common selection mistakes to evaluation criteria and technology solutions. You’ll learn how to balance cost, speed, and reliability while leveraging tools like carrier selection software and multi-warehouse optimization to streamline operations.

What is carrier selection?

Carrier selection is the strategic process of choosing shipping partners that align with your business needs and customer expectations. You must evaluate service levels, costs, delivery timeframes, and specialized capabilities to find the right fit for your ecommerce operations.

Consider these three main carrier types:

• National carriers: Major providers like UPS, FedEx, and USPS with broad coverage and diverse service options. While competitive for many shipments, they may not be the most cost-effective for certain products or regions.
• Regional carriers: Smaller, localized providers offering flexible service and better rates within specific geographic areas. Ideal for businesses with concentrated customer bases but limited for nationwide operations.
• Specialized carriers: Providers handling specific product types like hazardous materials, temperature-controlled items, or freight. They provide necessary expertise but typically at higher costs with more limited coverage.

Today, carrier selection directly impacts your profitability, customer satisfaction, and brand reputation. The right carrier mix gives you a competitive advantage by optimizing shipping operations and meeting customer expectations.

The importance of carrier diversification

Modern shipping strategy emphasizes using multiple carriers instead of relying on a single provider. This approach offers key benefits:

• Flexibility: Select the best carrier for each shipment based on cost, transit time, and delivery location.
• Redundancy: Protect against disruptions by quickly switching carriers when issues arise.
• Negotiating power: Secure better rates as carriers compete for your shipping volume.
• Scalability: Grow more easily by leveraging different carriers’ regional strengths and specialized services.

While managing multiple carriers can be challenging, technology solutions like transportation management systems (TMS) and multi-carrier shipping software automate selection, rate shopping, and performance tracking to simplify decisions.

By strategically diversifying your carrier mix and using technology for data-driven decisions, you can build resilient, cost-effective shipping operations that satisfy customers and support long-term growth.

“Even during other periods of uncertainty, ShipBob is able to ensure our operations are seamless and quickly adapt. During the recent Canada Post strike, ShipBob handled the situation with such grace, shipping orders with alternative carriers without interruption. I didn’t even have to think about it. ShipBob is our built-in supply chain control tower, proactively finding solutions to problems, which is wonderful.”

– Jessica Stoller, Director of Supply Chain and Operations at Arrae 

Why is researching carriers before making a selection important?

Thorough carrier research directly impacts your bottom line, customer experience, and operational efficiency. Without it, you risk product damage, delivery failures, and excessive costs that hurt your business.

Today’s shipping market offers more options than ever, creating better rates but making selection more complex. Effective research means analyzing key metrics like on-time delivery rates and service quality, with many carriers publishing performance data to help your evaluation.

The wrong carrier choice can damage your brand reputation through mishandled packages and missed deadlines, driving frustrated customers to competitors. For specialized shipments like temperature-controlled or hazardous items, verifying proper certifications and equipment is essential to avoid compliance issues and product damage.

Strategic research helps you find partners that meet your core requirements while aligning with your brand values, including sustainability initiatives like eco-friendly packaging. By investing time in carrier research now, you’ll create a solid foundation for your shipping strategy and avoid costly mistakes down the road.

7 common carrier selection mistakes

Selecting the right shipping carriers is a complex process that requires careful consideration of multiple factors. However, many ecommerce businesses make common mistakes that can lead to increased costs, delivery delays, and customer dissatisfaction.

1. Focusing solely on cost

Many businesses choose carriers based only on price, but the cheapest option often costs more in the long run. Budget carriers may sacrifice reliability and service quality, leading to hidden expenses from delays and damages.

For example, a carrier with attractive base rates might add substantial fees for fuel, residential deliveries, or weekend service that quickly eliminate any savings.

Instead, adopt a total cost approach that considers on-time delivery rates and customer satisfaction. A slightly more expensive carrier with proven reliability typically delivers better overall value.

2. Overlooking specialized shipping needs

Don’t ignore your products’ specific shipping requirements. Hazardous materials, temperature-sensitive items, and oversized packages need carriers with proper certifications and equipment.

Using standard carriers for specialized shipments risks compliance issues and product damage. For instance, shipping temperature-sensitive pharmaceuticals with a general carrier could lead to spoilage and safety concerns.

Before selecting carriers, identify your unique shipping needs and find partners with the expertise and infrastructure to handle them properly.

3. Neglecting reliability and on-time performance

While searching for quick, affordable shipping, many businesses overlook reliability.

Carriers with histories of delays and damages quickly erode customer trust. According to ShipStation, 69% of consumers won’t shop with a retailer again after a poor delivery experience.

Track key metrics like on-time delivery percentages and exception rates when evaluating carriers. Prioritize consistent reliability, as it directly impacts your reputation and revenue.

4. Underestimating compliance requirements

Shipping involves numerous regulations from customs requirements to hazardous materials restrictions. Ignoring these can result in delays, fines, and legal issues.

Incorrect tariff codes or missing documentation can cause border delays and extra fees. Improperly packaged hazardous materials might be refused by carriers or result in penalties.

When selecting carriers, evaluate their regulatory expertise and ability to provide proper documentation support for your specific shipping needs.

5. Ignoring sustainability factors

Sustainable shipping is no longer optional; it’s a business necessity. Overlooking environmental practices can disadvantage your brand with eco-conscious consumers.

Nielsen reports 73% of consumers would change their habits to reduce environmental impact. In response, many carriers now offer green initiatives like electric vehicles and carbon offset programs.

Choose carriers committed to sustainability to reduce your carbon footprint, appeal to environmentally aware customers, and stand out in a competitive market.

6. Missing out on multi-warehouse advantages

Relying on a single warehouse location limits your shipping options and efficiency. As your business grows, this approach leads to higher costs and slower deliveries.

Distributing inventory across multiple locations reduces shipping distances and transit times by fulfilling orders from facilities closest to customers. This strategy also lets you leverage regional carriers for better rates and service.

Multi-warehouse distribution provides flexibility when carriers face constraints or disruptions. Choose carriers that integrate well with distributed fulfillment networks and maintain consistent service across locations.

7. Overcomplicating the brand experience

Using too many different carriers creates an inconsistent customer experience. When packages arrive via multiple carriers with varying tracking capabilities and delivery practices, it confuses customers and weakens brand trust.

Inconsistent handling also affects packaging presentation and product integrity, potentially disappointing customers during unboxing.

Streamline your carrier mix and maintain clear communication throughout the shipping process. Consider carriers’ packaging options, tracking capabilities, and delivery notifications to create a unified brand experience from checkout to delivery.

6 top criteria for choosing the right shipping carriers

Selecting the right shipping carriers directly impacts your bottom line, customer satisfaction, and operational efficiency. Here are six essential factors to consider when evaluating potential shipping partners.

1. Cost and geographic coverage

Look beyond base rates to assess the full cost structure, including fuel surcharges, residential delivery fees, and accessorial charges. Calculate the total cost for your common shipment types and consider dimensional weight pricing and minimum package charges.

Evaluate each carrier’s geographic coverage against your customer distribution. Choose carriers with strong presence in regions where your customers are concentrated for better delivery speed and reliability. For international shipping, assess global networks and customs clearance capabilities.

When negotiating rates, leverage your shipping volume and growth potential. Provide data on your shipping patterns and projected growth to demonstrate your value. Compare offers from multiple carriers to secure the best rates and service levels.

2. Reliability and on-time performance

Reliability directly affects customer satisfaction and loyalty. Late or damaged deliveries lead to complaints, returns, and lost customers, damaging your reputation and revenue.

Track key metrics like on-time delivery percentage, exception rates, and average transit times. Research carrier performance through industry reports, customer reviews, and third-party logistics providers.

Look for carriers with consistent service, especially during peak seasons. Consider implementing a carrier scorecard system to hold partners accountable and track performance over time.

3. Capacity and scalability

Choose carriers that can grow with your business and adapt to changing needs. Assess their ability to handle your current volume and projected growth by asking about network capacity, fleet size, and planned infrastructure investments.

Evaluate their peak season planning and contingency management. Ask how they prepare for volume spikes and what measures ensure on-time deliveries during busy periods. Inquire about volume caps that might affect capacity during peak times.

Mitigate capacity risks by partnering with multiple carriers or working with a fulfillment provider like ShipBob that can distribute volume across a carrier network. This creates a more resilient shipping strategy that adapts to changing market conditions.

4. Special service capabilities

Evaluate carriers’ specialized services beyond standard ground delivery. For premium shipping options like overnight or same-day delivery, look for carriers with strong expedited service records, comprehensive network coverage, and reliable delivery guarantees.

For international shipping, assess global networks, customs clearance capabilities, and expertise in navigating trade regulations. Choose carriers with strong presence in your key international markets.

If your products need special handling (temperature control, hazardous materials, fragile items), verify carriers have the necessary equipment, trained personnel, and certifications. Matching your shipping needs with specialized carrier capabilities ensures better customer experiences with fewer problems.

5. Technology and carrier selection software

Choose carriers with robust technology platforms and integration capabilities. Carrier APIs and web services enable real-time rate shopping, label printing, and tracking updates, reducing manual work and improving accuracy.

Consider implementing carrier selection software or a transportation management system (TMS) to automate shipping decisions.

Look for features like:

• Real-time rate comparison across multiple carriers
• Automated carrier selection based on your business rules
• Integration with your ecommerce platform and other systems
• Comprehensive reporting and analytics
• Customizable shipping documents that meet all requirements

These tools help you make data-driven decisions while reducing manual effort and improving accuracy.

6. Sustainability and green shipping initiatives

As consumers prioritize environmental responsibility, sustainability is becoming crucial in carrier selection. Evaluate carriers’ commitment to eco-friendly practices, including electric vehicles, route optimization, and sustainable packaging.

Offer green shipping options like carbon-neutral delivery or eco-friendly packaging to appeal to environmentally conscious customers. Many carriers now provide carbon offset programs that can enhance your brand reputation.

Balance sustainability with cost and speed by implementing a multi-carrier strategy that includes both traditional and green options. Give customers choices and highlight the environmental benefits of each option to appeal to different preferences.

Prioritizing sustainability helps align your operations with customer values, differentiate your brand, and contribute to a more sustainable future for logistics.

Understanding carrier selection software and TMS solutions

Carrier selection software and transportation management systems (TMS) automate shipping decisions and operations. These tools compare rates and select carriers automatically, saving time and reducing errors.

The software connects to your ecommerce platform to provide real-time shipping visibility. It automatically selects the best carrier for each order based on your rules for speed, cost, and reliability.

Key features to look for:

• Real-time rate comparison across carriers
• Customizable rules for carrier selection
• Integration with major and regional carriers
• Automated label printing
• Unified tracking for all shipments
• Performance and cost analytics

Full TMS solutions offer additional capabilities like route optimization and freight payment processing for more complex operations.

When choosing a solution, consider:

• Scalability: Will it grow with your business?
• Usability: Is it easy to learn and use?
• Integration: Does it work with your existing systems?
• Carrier network: Does it support your needed carriers?
• Reporting: Does it provide useful insights?

Benefits include:

• Lower shipping costs through automatic rate optimization
• Faster, more reliable deliveries
• Better customer experience with accurate tracking
• Time savings from automation
• Greater visibility into shipping operations

These tools offer substantial ROI by cutting costs, improving efficiency, and enhancing customer satisfaction, helping you stay competitive in today’s market.

“What impressed me most was their robust software, which also has all of the carrier’s rates and carrier selection logic. For example, if we want to sell a certain product, we can see which carrier can send it the cheapest: DHL, FedEx, USPS, and even others. The ability to have variable costs and competitive pricing for shipping is important to us. That’s ultimately why we chose ShipBob. Compared to fulfilling orders from our warehouses, our shipping costs have come down since partnering with ShipBob.”

– John Lewis, President and COO of Vision Investments

The outsourced advantage: Removing complexity for ecommerce brands

Brands can simplify carrier management by outsourcing fulfillment. Fulfillment partners act as intermediaries between your business and shipping carriers and combine shipping volume from multiple merchants to negotiate better rates than you could get alone.

Key benefits of working with a fulfillment partner:

• Discounted rates across multiple carriers
• Automated carrier selection based on your requirements
• Unified platform with integrated tracking and reporting

ShipBob’s carrier selection algorithm allows us to rate shop to find you the most optimal shipping option for each order. This approach eliminates manual rate comparison, providing customers with reliable shipping options, and gives you access to pre-negotiated rates without the need to manage carrier relationships yourself. With ShipBob, you can focus on growing your business instead of managing complex shipping logistics.

“Because of ShipBob’s overall order volume, they can negotiate bulk discounts with carriers that we simply couldn’t. By partnering with ShipBob, we get better quality fulfillment and shipping for a better price.”

– Maria Osorio, Logistics and Operations Director at Oxford Healthspan

How multi-warehouse optimization streamlines carrier selection

Multi-warehouse fulfillment strategies meet elevated customer expectations by distributing inventory across multiple locations to reduce shipping distances, costs, and transit times.

This approach offers several advantages for carrier selection:

• Reduced shipping distances by storing inventory closer to customers
• Access to cost-effective regional carriers specialized in specific geographic areas
• Improved flexibility and resilience against disruptions in any single region
• Ability to test and optimize carrier performance across different regions

ShipBob’s fulfillment network puts this strategy into action with strategically located centers across the US, Canada, the UK, the EU, and Australia. Their technology automatically routes each order to the optimal fulfillment center and carrier combination based on inventory availability, destination, and delivery requirements.

For example, a Los Angeles customer’s order might route to ShipBob’s Moreno Valley facility using regional carriers, while a New York order ships from our Bethlehem, Pennsylvania fulfillment center. This intelligent routing happens automatically without requiring merchant intervention.

By partnering with ShipBob’s multi-warehouse network, merchants can optimize carrier selection without complex analysis or manual work. This data-driven approach helps businesses reduce shipping costs, improve delivery times, and create exceptional customer experiences that drive growth.

Scaling global fulfillment: Cross-border considerations

As ecommerce continues to break down geographic barriers, many businesses are looking to expand their reach and tap into new international markets. However, scaling global fulfillment and optimizing cross-border shipping can be a complex and challenging endeavor, with numerous factors to consider when selecting carriers and managing logistics.

One of the primary challenges of international shipping is navigating the complex web of customs regulations, tariffs, and documentation requirements that vary by country and region. Each market has its own unique set of rules and regulations governing the import and export of goods, and failure to comply with these requirements can result in delays, additional costs, and even legal penalties.

When selecting carriers for international shipping, it’s essential to look for providers with deep expertise in cross-border logistics and a proven track record of successfully navigating customs clearance and compliance. Carriers with a strong global network and established relationships with local customs authorities can help ensure smooth and efficient processing of international shipments, minimizing the risk of delays or additional costs.

“Having a partner like ShipBob that allows us to tap into all of the various UK carriers has been unmatched. And the flexibility of being able to send orders abroad is really nice. A lot of competitors in the UK only let you fulfill orders domestically within the UK, and if you want to ship orders to Europe, you have to find warehouse space on the mainland and ship from there. That’s not economically friendly for a growing company like ours. ShipBob’s adaptability and support for scaling orders to customers regardless of location has been great for ARTAH.” 

– Connor Stewart, Head of Operations + Impact at ARTAH 

Want to outsource carrier selection to a leading fulfillment partner?

Managing carriers, negotiating rates, and optimizing shipping takes time and expertise many ecommerce brands lack. Partner with ShipBob to eliminate these headaches while accessing enterprise-level shipping capabilities.

Eliminate complexity with automated carrier selection

ShipBob simplifies shipping decisions. Instead of comparing carriers for every order, just map your store’s shipping options (like “Standard” or “2-Day”) to our service levels. Our system automatically selects the best carrier based on destination, service level, and package details.

Access discounted rates unavailable to individual merchants

As a high-volume shipper, ShipBob negotiates better rates with national, regional, and specialized carriers than merchants could get alone. We pass these savings directly to you, boosting your margins while maintaining quality service.

Leverage intelligent technology for optimized shipping

When customers select “Standard Shipping” at checkout, our system instantly evaluates all carrier options to find the most cost-effective solution that meets the delivery promise. This ensures optimal carrier selection without any manual work on your part.

Enjoy simple setup with seamless customer experience

To start, map your existing shipping options to ShipBob’s service levels in our dashboard. This one-time setup keeps your customer experience consistent while our technology handles the complex decisions behind the scenes.

Focus on growth while we handle logistics

By letting ShipBob manage your carriers, you free up valuable time for product development, marketing, and other growth initiatives. Our merchants save significant time by eliminating carrier management tasks like rate negotiation and performance tracking.

Maintain control with customizable shipping rules

Need specific carrier preferences? Our platform offers customizable rules that let you prioritize certain carriers for specific regions, products, or service levels while still optimizing all other shipments.

Start shipping with ShipBob

Ready to simplify your shipping operations? Request a quote today to learn how ShipBob can help you deliver faster, more reliable shipping at lower costs.

FAQs about carrier selection

Below are answers to common queries and challenges experienced by merchants when exploring their carrier selection options.

This article originally appeared on ShipBob and is available here for further discovery.