HomePodcastWhy Your Store is Bleeding Money (While You Chase More Traffic)

Why Your Store is Bleeding Money (While You Chase More Traffic)

Episode Introduction

Welcome back to eCommerce Fastlane! Here’s a story that might sound familiar: you’re spending $10,000+ a month on ads, traffic looks solid, but somehow you’re barely breaking even. Sound familiar?

The hard truth is that most Shopify merchants don’t realize they have a revenue leak problem. While you’re obsessing over getting more traffic, your store is quietly bleeding money through hidden conversion killers and psychological friction points that drive customers away.

I see it every BFCM season—brands celebrate stellar top-line numbers only to discover their net profit has vanished into the red. The real challenge isn’t getting more eyeballs; it’s plugging the invisible leaks that are costing you thousands every month.

My guest today is Matt Stafford, Managing Partner at Build Grow Scale. Matt’s been in the trenches for nearly 30 years, scaling multiple 7- and 8-figure brands and helping close to a thousand founders break through growth plateaus. But here’s what makes him different: he doesn’t just tweak conversion rates—he decodes the psychology behind why people buy and why they don’t.

Matt learned this the hard way. After selling $15 million in t-shirts, he launched a kitchen gadgets store that was crushing it at 100-200 sales per day…until it suddenly wasn’t. Orders dropped to 30-40 per day, and with hundreds of thousands in inventory on the way, he had to figure it out fast.

That crisis became his breakthrough—and today, he’s going to share the frameworks that can help you stop the bleeding and start scaling profitably.

What You’ll Learn

✅ The Most Common “Revenue Leaks” Killing Profits (while merchants obsess over getting more traffic)
✅ Why Adding More Products Usually Destroys Conversions: The Paradox of Choice Problem
✅ The Power of Post-Purchase Feedback: The Single Thank-You Page Question That Unlocked $6M
✅ Simple Checkout Optimizations That Reduce Form Errors 3x (and consistently lift conversions)
✅ How AI Is Quietly Revolutionizing Store Optimization, Customer Support, and Strategic Planning
✅ Why the Biggest Business Bottlenecks Are in the Founder’s Head (not on the page)
✅ Practical Strategies for Leveraging AI Search, LLMs, and Conversational Commerce Channels

Episode Sponsor: Instant

Right now, 98% of your site traffic is anonymous. Meta knows who these visitors are, but once they hit your site and leave without giving you their email… that $2 CPC you just paid is gone.

Instant solves this by matching your anonymous site traffic with email addresses, allowing you to trigger smarter retention flows and recover revenue that would otherwise disappear.

Take Karen Kane – they drove $707k in incremental flow revenue in just 60 days using Instant’s visitor identification technology.

Major brands like Liquid I.V., Third Love, and Truly Beauty are seeing an average ROI of 21.7x with Instant. The median ROI across all their clients is 11.8x, and they’re confident enough in their results to guarantee a 4x ROI.

The concept is straightforward: identify anonymous visitors, retarget shoppers with personalized email flows, and increase your overall media spend effectiveness.

Instant is offering podcast listeners 50% off their platform, plus they’ll set up a demo to show you exactly how it works.

Get 50% Off Your First Month →

Episode Summary

Here’s the painful truth: while you’re obsessing over getting more traffic, your store is quietly bleeding money through conversion killers you don’t even know exist.

Matt Stafford learned this the hard way. After selling $15 million in t-shirts, he launched a kitchen gadgets store that was crushing it at 100-200 sales per day—until it wasn’t. Orders dropped to 30-40 per day, and with hundreds of thousands in inventory on the way, he had to figure it out fast.

The culprit? His site was taking 11+ seconds to load (cached on his computer, so he never saw it). A 70% bounce rate meant he was really only getting 300 visitors instead of 1,000. Fix the speed, double the business instantly.

This crisis became Matt’s breakthrough: most Shopify brands don’t have a traffic problem—they have a conversion problem.

Matt breaks down Build Grow Scale’s principle-based approach that’s generated millions for their clients. The 80/20 rule in action: take your top 20% of products driving 80% of revenue and make them impossible to miss. Stop hiding bestsellers in generic “Shop” menus. Simplify navigation so customers can actually find what they’re looking for—because search and filtered traffic converts 2x higher and spends 2-4x more.

The game-changer? Post-purchase feedback. Matt’s team asks every customer: “What almost made you not buy?” One client got 520 responses in seven days—460 complained the sales video was too long. Solution: add a speed control option. Result: 10% conversion lift worth $6 million annually.

For checkout optimization, Matt shares the one tweak that’s never failed: adding “required for order confirmation” under the email field reduces errors by 270% and can boost conversions up to 17%. It’s pure psychology—people need a reason why.

AI is quietly revolutionizing optimization too. Smart chatbots are cutting customer service teams from 13 to 5 people while boosting satisfaction from 35% to 92%. AI can analyze massive data sets to build 90-day roadmaps that humans never would have conceived.

But here’s Matt’s biggest insight: the real bottlenecks aren’t on the page—they’re in the founder’s head. The brands that win consistently know their numbers, obsess over customer experience, and understand that business is ultimately people doing business with people.

If what Matthew shared resonated with you and you’re ready to turn more of your existing traffic into actual customers, then book a strategy call with the Build Grow Scale team. No pressure. Just real insights into what’s holding your store back and what to fix first.

Book a Strategy Call here: https://buildgrowscale.com/book-a-call

Key Insights

Site Speed Is Your Silent Killer: Matt’s own store was losing 70% of visitors due to an 11+ second load time he couldn’t see on his cached browser. Fix the speed, double the business instantly—because you can’t convert traffic that bounces before your page loads.
Stop Hiding Your Winners: Most stores bury their top 20% of products (that drive 80% of revenue) in generic “Shop” menus. Make your bestsellers impossible to miss—search and filtered traffic converts 2x higher and spends 2-4x more than average site visitors.
The $6 Million Question: Ask every customer on your thank-you page: “What almost made you not buy?” One brand got 520 responses in seven days—460 complained the sales video was too long.
Psychology Beats Design in Checkout: Adding “required for order confirmation” under email fields reduces errors by 270% and can boost conversions up to 17%. People need a reason why—give them one and watch completion rates soar.
AI Is Cutting Payroll, Not Just Costs: Smart chatbots are reducing customer service teams from 13 to 5 people while boosting satisfaction from 35% to 92%. AI never has a bad day and works 24/7—but the key is feeding it quality training data about your products and policies.
Your Biggest Bottleneck Isn’t Technical: The real constraints are in the founder’s head, not on the page. Successful brands consistently invest in personal development alongside business metrics—because business is ultimately people doing business with people.
LLMs Are Scraping New Sources: ChatGPT and other AI models primarily pull recommendations from Quora and Reddit threads, not traditional SEO content. Getting your brand into influential forum conversations can shortcut years of traditional SEO work.

Guest Spotlight

Matt Stafford is a 30-year eCommerce veteran who’s learned the hard way what separates winning stores from struggling ones. After selling $15 million in t-shirts, he launched a kitchen gadgets store that was crushing it at 100-200 orders per day—until a hidden site speed issue he couldn’t see on his cached browser dropped sales to just 30-40 per day, with hundreds of thousands in inventory on the way.

That crisis became his breakthrough. Today, as Managing Partner of Build Grow Scale, Matt leads a 35-person team that works with 12-14 high-volume brands at a time (typically $250K-$5M per month), helping close to 1,000 eCommerce merchants unlock hidden profits through principle-based optimization.

His superpower isn’t chasing the latest “shiny object” hacks—it’s understanding human psychology and removing the friction points that silently bleed revenue from even sophisticated stores. Matt also coaches founders on the “internal game,” recognizing that the biggest business bottlenecks often live in the entrepreneur’s head, not on the page.

Ready to plug your revenue leaks and break through your growth plateau? Visit BuildGrowScale.com for free resources, mentorship programs, and done-for-you optimization services that turn conversion problems into profit engines.

Guest Information

Matt Stafford
Managing Partner at Build Grow Scale

Links & Resources

Thanks for Supporting the Pod!

Over the past eight seasons, I’ve been incredibly lucky to chat with some of the brightest founders in ecommerce building remarkable Shopify brands and partners shaping the app and marketing ecosystem. Honestly, every conversation has taught me something new, and I’m grateful for the chance to learn alongside you.

What matters most is that this podcast helps you solve real challenges and unlock new growth for your business. Your support, feedback, and stories have made this journey truly special. Thanks for tuning in, sharing your wins, losses, and being part of the eCommerce Fastlane community.

Leave an Honest Rating/Review:Share your thoughts on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Follow & Subscribe on YouTube:Get notified about new episodes on YouTube.