HomePodcastThe $1.2M Revenue Recovery System That Identifies 5x More Visitors Than Your Competitors

The $1.2M Revenue Recovery System That Identifies 5x More Visitors Than Your Competitors

Welcome back to eCommerce Fastlane! Here’s a painful reality that’s quietly killing Shopify brands: you’re spending thousands driving traffic to your store, but 98% of those visitors are complete ghosts.

They browse, they leave, and you have zero way to bring them back—while your competitors who’ve cracked visitor identification are building massive email lists from the exact same traffic.

If you’re feeling the squeeze of rising acquisition costs while retention gets tougher thanks to the cookie apocalypse, this episode is your wake-up call.

My guest today is Liam Millward, Co-Founder and CEO of Instant. After working with 1,000+ Shopify brands—including headliners like Liquid I.V., July Luggage, and The Oodie—Liam’s team has cracked the code on turning “anonymous” traffic into high-ROI repeat customers.

While most brands are still playing the “pray they come back” game with tools that identify maybe 5% of visitors, Instant routinely identifies 40-60%—turning anonymous browsers into revenue-generating customers. We’re talking about brands like July Luggage adding $1.2M in incremental revenue in just 10 months, and College & Co seeing 62x ROI in their first 30 days.

Today, Liam reveals why most retention solutions are leaving money on the table, how AI-powered flows are eliminating the manual email grind, and why the brands implementing smarter identification now are building unfair advantages for Q4—while their competitors will be fighting for scraps from traffic they can’t even track.

What You’ll Learn

✅ How Instant identifies 5–10x more anonymous site visitors (and plugs them straight into your retention flows)

✅ Why “remembering” your shoppers—across platforms and devices—is the next frontier after the cookie apocalypse

✅ How plug-and-play setup gets you live and generating incremental revenue in under 72 hours (with zero tech headaches)

✅ The ROI math: how July Luggage added $1.2M in 10 months and College & Co saw 62x ROI in 30 days—without buying new traffic

✅ Instant’s AI engine: how it crafts, updates, and personalizes retention emails in real time, auto-syncing with your latest offers and branding

✅ Predictive Opt-In: a smarter way to time pop-ups (and massively lift email capture rates)

✅ Q4 Playbook: why onboarding now sets you up for massive wins come Black Friday/Cyber Monday—thanks to longer data retention and smarter recapture

Episode Summary

Here’s the brutal reality most Shopify stores won’t admit: you’re obsessing over traffic while 98% of your visitors vanish forever—and your competitors who’ve cracked visitor identification are building massive email lists from the exact same traffic.

The old-school playbook of “opt-in popups and manual Klaviyo tweaks” barely scratches the surface—especially as cookies disappear and cross-device tracking fragments.

Instant’s magic is stitching together disparate data (cookies, server-side, IP, marketing platforms) to “remember” far more shoppers—unlocking a pool of revenue brands didn’t realize they had. Instead of capturing 10–12% of visitor emails, clients routinely hit 40–60%. Every extra email plugged into retention flows is a shot at winning back high-intent, high-value customers.

The results? SMBs see consistent 8x+ ROI, with some hitting 62x (like College & Co.—$150K in 30 days from 20,000 retargeted shoppers). Setup is as easy as pasting a JS pixel and cloning flows—live in under three days.

While most brands are still playing the “pray they come back” game, Instant users are building unfair advantages that compound daily—especially heading into the biggest shopping season of the year.

The AI layer is Instant’s second ace. It continuously analyzes your brand’s website, logo, live offers, and segment behavior, using it to create and refresh retention flows on the fly. Black Friday/Cyber Monday code changes? The emails update themselves. Predictive pop-ups trigger at the perfect moment for each visitor. Send times? Dynamically optimized for each customer.

Want to maximize Q4? Brands that switch Instant on early reap the biggest rewards (thanks to months of data-building, so return visitors during BFCM are identified and primed for retargeting).

Strategic Takeaways

The Cookie Apocalypse Created a Winner-Take-All Scenario: While most brands lost 60-70% of their retargeting ability when cookies disappeared, those who solve visitor identification now own a disproportionate advantage. The gap between brands that can identify 40-60% of visitors versus those stuck at 10-12% isn’t just a metric—it’s a moat.

Retention Marketing Just Became Your Highest-ROI Channel: When you can identify 5x more visitors, email marketing ROI jumps from “decent” to “money printing machine” territory. Brands like July Luggage adding $1.2M in 10 months and College & Co seeing 62x ROI aren’t outliers—they’re the new baseline for operators who get this right.

Q4 Is Make-or-Break for Early Adopters: The brands implementing visitor identification now will have months of behavioral data while competitors scramble with Black Friday strangers. That shopper who browsed your site in June but didn’t buy? With proper identification, they become a known quantity during your biggest sales period instead of another anonymous visitor.

AI Finally Delivers on the Email Marketing Promise: No more “set it and forget it” campaigns that break the moment you update your branding. We’re talking about emails that actually evolve with your campaigns, automatically update with new codes, and send at each customer’s optimal conversion time. The brands leveraging this level of automation are operating at speeds their competitors can’t match.

The Math Is Simple, But the Window Is Closing: Every day you’re not identifying anonymous visitors is a day your competitors are building massive email lists from the same traffic you’re both paying for. Early movers aren’t just getting better results—they’re building compound advantages that become nearly impossible to overcome.

Guest Spotlight

Liam Millward is Co-Founder and CEO of Instant, the retention platform that’s quietly helping over 1,000 Shopify brands turn anonymous traffic into serious revenue—while their competitors wonder where all the sales went.

After watching brands burn thousands on traffic only to lose 98% of visitors forever, Liam built a system that identifies 40-60% of anonymous visitors (versus the typical 10-12%) and plugs them straight into retention flows. We’re talking about brands like July Luggage adding $1.2M in 10 months and College & Co seeing 62x ROI in their first 30 days—all from traffic they were already paying for.

While most brands are still playing the “pray they come back” game in the post-cookie era, Liam’s clients are building unfair advantages that compound daily—especially heading into Q4 when visitor identification becomes the difference between record sales and watching competitors win.

Ready to turn your ghost traffic into revenue before the Q4 rush?

Visit Instant for your free demo, ROI projection, and 50% off your first month exclusively for Fastlane listeners.

Guest Information

Liam Millward
Co-Founder & CEO, Instant

Links & Resources

Thanks for Supporting the Pod!

Over the past eight seasons, I’ve been incredibly lucky to chat with some of the brightest founders in ecommerce building remarkable Shopify brands and partners shaping the app and marketing ecosystem. Honestly, every conversation has taught me something new, and I’m grateful for the chance to learn alongside you.

What matters most is that this podcast helps you solve real challenges and unlock new growth for your business. Your support, feedback, and stories have made this journey truly special. Thanks for tuning in, sharing your wins, losses, and being part of the eCommerce Fastlane community.

Leave an Honest Rating/Review:Share your thoughts on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Follow & Subscribe on YouTube:Get notified about new episodes on YouTube.