The Good And The Bad: Assessing Some Of Todd Boehly’s Signings At Chelsea

In the summer of 2022, American businessman Todd Boehly made headlines by purchasing Chelsea from fan favourite Roman Abramovich for a record £4.25 billion.

This marked the end of Abramovich’s 19-year reign, during which he funded Chelsea’s most successful period — winning multiple Premier Leagues, FA Cups, and Champions Leagues.

Since Boehly’s arrival, he has invested over £1 billion to reshape the team and elevate Chelsea’s standing in the football betting odds.

However, the results on the pitch have been less than stellar — leading to Mauricio Pochettino becoming the fourth coach to navigate the turbulent waters under Boehly’s ownership.

While the manager often shoulders the blame in modern football, the impact of player acquisitions cannot be ignored.

Let’s delve into some of Todd Boehly’s significant signings over the past 18 months and assess whether they have been successful or not.

Key Takeaways:

• Strategic Investments: Chelsea’s recruitment strategy under Todd Boehly emphasizes investing in young talent with potential for growth, such as Enzo Fernández, Wesley Fofana, and Mykhaylo Mudryk, reflecting a long-term vision for the club’s success.
• Mixed Results: The performance of new signings has been mixed, with some players like Raheem Sterling making immediate impacts, while others like Noni Madueke and Kalidou Koulibaly have yet to meet expectations, underscoring the unpredictable nature of transfer success.
• Financial Management: Chelsea’s approach under Boehly shows a willingness to invest heavily in the transfer market, yet the club remains mindful of financial regulations, illustrating a balance between ambition and compliance.
• Adaptation and Integration: The varied performance of signings highlights the challenges of adapting to the Premier League, stressing the importance of patience and support in integrating new players into the team.
• Future Outlook: With ongoing links to high-profile players and a clear ambition to strengthen the squad, Chelsea’s transfer activity under Boehly signals an aggressive approach to competing at the highest levels, both domestically and in Europe.

Good: Cole Palmer

One of the surprises of the summer transfer window was the arrival of Cole Palmer, secured for £40 million from Manchester City on Deadline Day.

Despite Mauricio Pochettino distancing himself from the decision, Palmer has become one of Chelsea’s standout players — contributing nine goals and four assists in just 17 Premier League appearances.

His adaptation to London life took time, but his impact on the pitch has been undeniable.

Bad: Noni Madueke

Signed from PSV Eindhoven for £29 million in January 2023, Noni Madueke’s Chelsea stint has been lacklustre — with only four goals and no assists in 26 games over the last 12 months.

While he did score in consecutive December games, the 21-year-old has yet to fully justify his price tag and potential. 

Previous disagreements with Pochettino add a layer of concern to his Chelsea journey.

Good: Raheem Sterling

Boehly’s first signing, Raheem Sterling, arrived from Manchester City for £47.5 million.

Initially slow to find his rhythm, Sterling has now become a pivotal part of Chelsea’s attacking force — boasting seven goals and seven assists in 24 appearances this season.

His resilience and improved form have silenced initial doubts, and Pochettino relies heavily on the England winger.

Bad: Kalidou Kouibaly

Kalidou Kouibaly’s year at Chelsea is one that fans would prefer to forget.

Signed from Napoli for around £30 million, the centre-back’s tenure was marred by inconsistent performances and injuries. 

His departure to the Saudi Pro League after just 12 months highlighted the disappointment of this particular signing.

Good: Enzo Fernandez

Boehly’s acquisition of Enzo Fernandez for £105 million after Argentina’s World Cup triumph, which, at the time, broke the Premier League record, has proven to be a sound investment.

The 23-year-old midfielder has consistently performed in the heart of the midfield, demonstrating promise with room for further improvement.

Fernandez has shown the ability to score crucial goals for Chelsea, as well as act as a knack for breaking down opposition attacks. 

Bad: Moises Caicedo

On the flip side, Moises Caicedo’s impact at Chelsea has yet to match the staggering £115 million spent to bring him in from Brighton.

Despite high expectations following impressive performances with the Seagulls, the 22-year-old is yet to showcase his worth in a Chelsea shirt.

Comparisons with other signings, such as Mykhailo Mudryk and Marc Cucurella, emphasise the disappointment surrounding Caicedo’s contribution.

—

Todd Boehly’s foray into the transfer market has yielded a mixed bag of results.

While some signings like Cole Palmer and Raheem Sterling have proven their worth, others, notably Kalidou Kouibaly and Moises Caicedo, have fallen short of expectations and left Chelsea unfavourable with those placing Premier League bets.

As Chelsea continue to navigate the challenges under new ownership, the success of future signings will be crucial in determining the club’s trajectory.