Key Takeaways

• Manual sorting is time-consuming especially for Shopify stores with big catalogs
• Smart merchandising blends data, design, and business strategy
• Automation, AI, and visual tools cut down work and increase results
• Merchandising tools follow three approaches:  rule-based control, visual merchandising, and AI-driven personalization
• The top apps let humans guide AI, not the other way around
• Merchandising improves KPIs like conversion rate, average order value, and revenue per visitor
• SortWise ranks first for offering rules, visuals, and AI in one app
• Its flat pricing and scalable design work for stores of all sizes

It has become a place to create a personal and smart shopping experience. Merchants on Shopify who want to boost sales, increase order value, and build loyal customers must take collection merchandising seriously. Since Shopify’s built-in tools are limited, a new set of apps now gives merchants better control and results.In 2025, the question is not whether to automate your merchandising. It’s about doing it the right way. The best tools offer more than sorting. They follow clear strategies that connect data, design, and business goals. Understanding how each type of tool works helps store owners make smart choices based on their unique goals.

Understanding the Strategy of Advanced Collection Merchandising

The way products are arranged on a collection page affects how people shop. It is not about what looks good. It is about showing the right products to the right people. Effective merchandising enhances product visibility, directs customers toward high-margin items, and lowers the bounce rate. Top tools go beyond Shopify’s defaults. They cut out extra work, help stores sell better, and give clear ways to track success.

Modern shoppers have high expectations. They want to find what they need fast and enjoy the process. Merchandising supports this by making the customer journey smooth and logical. Whether the shopper is looking for bestsellers, new items, or deals, a well-merchandised collection page gives them exactly that. Merchandising is not about aesthetics. It drives conversions, supports upselling, and builds trust.

Why Automation Matters

Sorting large product lists by hand takes a lot of time. Store owners often move products one by one to show new items, hide sold-out ones, or feature bestsellers. These tasks can take hours and are easy to get wrong. Good apps use smart rules and AI to handle this automatically, saving time and avoiding mistakes.

Manual sorting also makes it hard to change things quickly. If product stock changes fast or if different pages need different layouts, it is hard to keep up. Automated tools help keep everything current and working well. This saves time and lets people focus on creative and important work.

Three Merchandising Philosophies

These apps follow three main ways to organize products. The best one to use depends on what each store wants to focus on.

• Rule-Based Control: Merchants can set clear rules to sort products. These rules are based on facts like stock levels, tags, or profit margin. This method gives full control and works well for teams that want to set things up and let it run. Rule-based merchandising is reliable and repeatable. It is ideal for stores that need to enforce strict standards, such as pushing low inventory items down or promoting high-margin items.
• Visual Merchandising: This approach lets users arrange products by hand in a drag-and-drop grid. It works best for brands that focus on style and need every detail to look right, like fashion or home goods. Visual merchandising lets a store tell a story with its layout. For example, a spring fashion launch might group pastel items together, while a home decor brand might feature matching sets.
• AI-Driven Personalization: AI sorts products in real time based on how visitors behave. It learns what shoppers like and adapts the page for each person. This is the most advanced option and works well for stores with high traffic. AI can personalize experiences based on behavior, geography, device, and more. This boosts engagement and increases the chances of conversion by showing customers exactly what they are most likely to buy.

The Human Touch: Blending Automation with Merchandiser Intuition

The best apps do not replace humans. They support them. A merchandiser sets rules, gives creative input, and decides when to override the AI. These tools are built to work with people, not instead of them. Merchandisers bring brand understanding, intuition, and creativity. Even the best AI cannot replace human judgment when it comes to seasonal themes, storytelling, or knowing what appeals to a specific audience.

Human-in-the-loop systems are especially valuable. They allow merchants to create a baseline of logic but still make manual adjustments when needed. For example, a brand may use rules to push bestsellers to the top but still want to highlight a new collection manually. With the right app, both goals are easy to achieve.

Measuring Success: KPIs Directly Influenced by Merchandising Excellence

Ultimately, the investment in a collection merchandising application must be justified by its impact on key business metrics like:

•  Conversion Rate
• Average Order Value (AOV)
• Revenue Per Visitor (RPV)
• Operational Efficiency
• Bounce Rate
• Inventory Turnover

Merchandising tools should make it easy to track results. Some apps integrate with Google Analytics or Shopify analytics. Others provide built-in reports that show how sorting strategies affect performance. When stores use data to guide their decisions, they become more agile and more profitable.

With this strategic framework in mind, here are the top 5 collection merchandising apps for Shopify in 2025.

Top 5 Collection Merchandising Apps for 2025

#5: Jedi Product & Collection Sort

Best for: Budget-Conscious Beginners

https://apps.shopify.com/coll-sort-push-down-sold-out-1

Jedi Sort earns its place on our list for one compelling reason: incredible value. For new stores or businesses on a tight budget, it provides the essential automation needed to escape the time-consuming task of manual sorting. With features like pushing out-of-stock items down and sorting by best-sellers, it’s a perfect first step into automated merchandising.

However, its capabilities, while effective, are foundational. As a business scales, the need for more granular rules, deeper analytics, and more sophisticated AI becomes apparent. Jedi is an excellent starting point, but ambitious merchants will likely find themselves graduating to a more comprehensive solution.

#4. Sort’d Collection Merchandiser

Best for: Purely Visual Brands

https://apps.shopify.com/stock-app

Sort’d is made for brands that care deeply about how their collections look. It is a great choice for fashion, luxury, and home goods stores that want full control over their product layout. Its drag-and-drop feature lets users place products by hand to create a clear and appealing display.

This hands-on style is also its biggest weakness. Sort’d has only basic automation and does not support complex rules or strong AI tools. It is best for brands that focus on looks, but may not work well for stores that need to grow fast or handle lots of products with limited time.

#3. ST: Product & Collection Sort

Best for: Data-Driven Power Users

https://apps.shopify.com/searchtap-merchandising-app

ST is is a good fit for a data-savvy merchandiser who lives in analytics and appreciates the Google Analytics 4 integration. The ability to sort collections based on metrics like Cart-to-View ratios or other engagement data provides a good level of precision.

This power, however, comes with a degree of complexity. ST is a tool for the analyst, and its visual merchandising capabilities, while present, are not its primary focus. It represents the “science” of merchandising exceptionally well but leaves some of the “art” on the table. It’s a formidable tool for those who need deep, data-specific control above all else.

#2. Kimonix

Best for: Large-Scale Enterprises

https://apps.shopify.com/kimonix

Kimonix is built for large companies that want to earn more by using advanced tools. It offers features like A/B testing and personal product sorting. These help big teams test what works best to get more sales. For very large brands, this can lead to big profits and make the higher price worth it.

But this tool is complex and costly. It takes time and experience to use it well. Kimonix works best for big businesses. For smaller stores, it may be too much and too expensive.

#1. SortWise Collection Sort

Best for: The Complete, All-in-One Solution for Modern Growth

https://apps.shopify.com/sortwise

In 2025, running a successful online store means using both creativity and smart tools. SortWise is the top choice because it brings together rules, design, and smart automation in one easy-to-use app that can grow with any business.

It takes the best ideas from its competitors and combines them into a superior, unified tool. 

• Hybrid Engine: SortWise gives you strong tools to organize your products using smart rules, like the ones in the ST app. You can sort items by things like price, stock, or popularity. It also lets you move products around by hand using a simple drag-and-drop layout, like the Sort’d app. With SortWise, you get the best of both features in one easy-to-use tool.
•  Accessible AI and Optimization: SortWise uses smart AI, like Kimonix, to sort products in a way that helps stores make more money or increase sales. But unlike Kimonix, it does not come with a high price. This makes SortWise a great choice for growing stores that want powerful tools without spending too much.
• Growth-Oriented Model: SortWise is made to grow with your business. Other apps may charge you more as your store gets busier or limit how much you can use their tools. SortWise gives you unlimited use with its main plans, so you can keep growing without extra costs.

SortWise has correctly identified that the future of merchandising is not about choosing between rules, visuals, or AI. It’s about having all three working in concert. It provides the depth of an enterprise tool, the creativity of a visual merchandiser, and the intelligence of an AI analyst in one elegant package. For any Shopify merchant looking to build a truly effective, efficient, and scalable merchandising strategy in 2025, SortWise is the clear and definitive choice.

Feature Comparison at a Glance

* (Unlimited Plan Only)

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Shopify collection merchandising?

Shopify collection merchandising is the process of organizing products within collection pages to guide customer browsing, highlight key items, and improve conversion rates.

Why is automated merchandising important for Shopify stores?

Manual sorting becomes inefficient as catalogs grow. Automated tools save time, ensure consistency, and adapt to business rules or customer behavior in real time.

What are the main types of merchandising strategies?

The three core strategies are rule-based sorting, visual merchandising, and AI-driven personalization. Most successful tools blend elements of all three.

How do merchandising apps impact KPIs?

Effective merchandising improves key metrics such as Conversion Rate, Average Order Value, Revenue Per Visitor, and Operational Efficiency.

What makes SortWise the top recommendation?

SortWise combines advanced rules, visual controls, and AI optimization in one scalable platform. It is cost-effective and suitable for brands of all sizes.

Can AI replace human merchandisers?

No. The best tools use AI to support not replace human judgment. Merchandisers remain essential for creative and strategic decisions.