• Explore. Learn. Thrive. Fastlane Media Network

  • ecommerceFastlane
  • PODFastlane
  • SEOfastlane
  • AdvisorFastlane
  • LifeFastlane

The Best Loyalty Rewards Tools For Ecommerce


Acquisition, acquisition, acquisition… Why is everyone so focused on getting a new customer when 41% of an Ecommerce store’s revenue comes from only 8% of its customers?

That’s where launching, and growing, a loyalty rewards program for your business comes in.

Your store can’t survive on new customers alone. By launching a loyalty program, you’ll be able to engage customers in a way that drives repeat purchases, referral, lifetime value, revenue, and most importantly, your profit margins.

Cut to the chase

Why Do You Need a Loyalty Program?

I want to emphasize the impact this has on profit, because you probably try everything to increase profit, from conversion rate optimization, to upselling, to tweaking pricing, to lowering your shipping costs… But loyalty is the fastest way to stronger profit margins. 

Why? Because your cost of acquisition (of a new purchase from an existing customer) is significantly lower than any other channel where you are acquiring a customer for the first time. 

And the deeper the loyalty, the true loyalty of the customer to the brand, the more they will refer others to you, share on social, and come back at cheaper and cheaper repeat “cost of acquisition,” or “re-acquisition.

Loyal Customers Cost Less

And to be clear, loyalty does have a cost. You may offer some sort of point rewards, discounts, or free products and that’s the cost you pay to get the customer coming back. But almost always, that cost is significantly lower than the cost you paid to get them to purchase in the first place. In fact, studies show it costs 5-25X more to acquire one customer than to keep one. If you’re not trying to find ways to engage your existing customers, you’re missing out on potential sales.

Also, being able to identify, and getting to know your best customers will allow you to fine tune and reduce your acquisition marketing costs. You may think you know your best customer, (maybe it’s “new moms”) but as you go through the process of enriching them, you may find the loyalty program shines through specifically on something different (i.e., certain geographic regions, moms of 2+, working moms, city moms, etc.). You are highly likely to find key insights as you build loyalty with your customers, and that will improve acquisition costs through the improved copywriting and targeting opportunities that come from getting to know them.

Win Back Lost Customers

Sooner or later, a loyal customer will forget about your brand, even if they’ve been buying from you for months or even years.

However, that doesn’t mean you should give up on lost customers.

A loyalty program will help you identify which customers you need to win back. You’ll be able to understand why they left in the first place, and optimize your campaigns to bring them back to your store.

True Brand Differentiation: Stand out From the Competition

A well-executed loyalty program delivers an exceptional user experience that delights and surprises customers. By rewarding customers for various shopping activities (reviews, purchases, etc.), you make them feel valued and give them a reason to come back and buy more products. This process simultaneously indoctrinates them into the brand, and brings them closer to you from a psychological standpoint (in a very healthy way).

A lot of marketing is purely emotional. By rewarding your customers, you’re treating them just like a friend — not like money. (They can be both!)

Boost Your Brands’ Reputation

In the age of the internet and social media, reputation is everything – especially for online brands where pretty much every customer reads reviews before they make a purchase.

There are two main ways that loyalty programs can boost your online reputation:

  1. First, you can encourage your store’s customers to leave a review in exchange for a reward. The rewards can include free samples, redeemable loyalty points, or product discounts.
  2. The second tactic is to ask customers for a review once they receive a reward. During this moment, they just had a positive experience with your brand, which makes them more likely to leave some kind words about your business.

It’s a simple and easy way to boost your online reviews, and position yourself as a brand that customers can trust.

Examples of Best In-Class Loyalty Programs

Loyalty programs have become a staple of many great businesses. Not only do they boost revenue and customer retention, but they also increase credibility and reputation as a brand.

Here are four brands killing it with retention and rewards marketing:

1. Sephora: Beauty Insider Program

Sephora is one of the leading brands in the beauty industry. They run a loyalty program called the Beauty Insider Program that is free for customers to join. More than 10 million of their customers are already part of the program.

Members of Sephora’s loyalty program earn redeemable points for each purchase they make. For their American customers, one point is equal to one dollar.

The program is divided into three tiers, which include:

  • Beauty insider: For members with 0-350 points.
  • VIB: For members who’ve spent more than $350 on Sephora products in one year.
  • VIB Rouge: For members who’ve spent more than $1000 on Sephora products in one year.

Every Tuesday and Wednesday, Sephora organizes their “Rewards Bazaar”, where customers can get exclusive rewards. We’re not just talking about any gifts — the Reward Bazaar offers products that customers won’t find anywhere else.

2. Adidas: Creator’s Club

Adidas has an exceptional loyalty program called Creator’s Club, a VIP member program where loyal customers get rewarded for their engagement. 

Members of the program can benefit from various exclusive perks, such as access to limited edition products, invitations to special events, and priority customer service. The more customers purchase products and attend Adidas events, the more rewards they get.

The VIP program includes four branded tiers to achieve rewards:

  • Challenger
  • Playmaker
  • Gamechanger
  • Icon

As customers grind up the levels and earn more points, they can unlock higher offers. For example, once they reach the Game Changer or Icon status, they can earn sweet rewards such as personalized training apps, custom workouts, or exclusive parties.

What makes Adidas’ program so great is that they could go beyond products and discounts. They offer their customer experiences, which proves they value them. 

3. Barnes & Noble: B&N Membership

Customers are more likely to join your loyalty program when they feel the value outweighs the cost to join.

Take a look at Barnes & Noble, for example, with their B&N Membership Program. When customers join, they can receive around $60 in discounts, bonus coupons, and other exclusive benefits, which include:

  • Free shipping
  • Special birthday offers
  • Early access to events

The best part? It only costs around $25 a year for customers to join. It’s an opportunity for them to get good value for their money.

4. Amazon: Amazon Prime

Last but not least, no one does brand loyalty better than Amazon with its Prime membership program.

The reason why Amazon Prime is so successful is because it addresses the most significant pain point of most online buyers: high shipping costs. By paying an annual fee, Amazon Prime members get access to unlimited 2-day shipping on any product they buy.

As a result, Amazon Prime members are spending four times the amount on products than non-members. Amazon Prime’s subscribers expect to double in this decade.

Tools That Are Related to Loyalty, but Not Quite Loyalty

It’s worth mentioning that there are some other types of tools that seem like loyalty tools, but are not.

Outside of loyalty programs, there are also other tools you can use to promote your online store and delight customers, which include:

  • Referral programs – they incentivize referring a friend and may even give a reward, but they don’t allow for any other types of loyalty outside referral.
  • Facebook Messenger & SMS marketing providers – these are great channels for marketing and for keeping in touch with customers, ergo they feel like they create “loyalty,” but in fact, they are just the medium of communication, not a full-fledged loyalty program.
  • Influencer marketing tools – keeping in touch with influencers and building an influencer program can build a certain type of loyalty with those influencers, but that is still not a loyalty program, and therefore this falls short of what we really want.

These tools share similar features, such as the ability to drive more customer engagement with your brand. However, they also have key differences that separate them.

Let’s find out why:

Referral Marketing Tools

With referral programs, the goal isn’t really to drive repeat purchases, it’s to land new customers. Customers are encouraged to spread the word and recommend your brand with others around them, typically using their own discount code or referral link.

Referral programs are merit-based, and rewards are only issued to the customer when a successful referral is made. 

Many referral marketing tools offer cash reward payouts, which is especially valuable in businesses with low repeat purchases (Example: Mattresses).

Examples of Referral Marketing Tools:

Facebook Messenger & SMS Marketing Tools

Facebook Messenger currently has 1.3 billion users worldwide. On top of that, 53% of people who use messaging apps to reach brands are more likely to shop with a business they can DM.

For a more personalized customer service experience, there are various tools you can use to set up a Facebook chatbot in your store. While they’re not loyalty programs, Facebook Messenger tools do similarly work to drive deeper engagement and retention.

Examples of Facebook Messenger & SMS Marketing tools:

Influencer Marketing Tools

There are many influencer marketing tools that help you build relationships and get free and paid promotion by micro and macro influencers. Some may encourage affiliates or partners to share about you, but they aren’t precisely customer-facing tools that boost loyalty.

Examples of Influencer Marketing Tools: 

As an Ecommerce store, you need a tool that builds loyalty programs that are frictionless, exclusive, and compelling enough for customers to join. The program you pick also depends on factors such as your current budget, company revenue, and specific needs.

To compile our list of the best loyalty tools, here’s what we took into account for each platform:

  • Easy-to-use user interface (UI) that helps you create loyalty programs in hours, not days
  • Advanced analytics that measures the performance of your loyalty program
  • Customization feature to create unique programs 
  • Simple integration with your favorite Ecommerce platforms and marketing tools

So without further ado, let’s take a look at six apps that are going to supercharge your customer retention and boost your revenue (in no particular order):


LoyaltyLion is a loyalty provider trusted by thousands of Ecommerce stores such as Ancient Nutrition, Skinny Dip, and more. 

With LoyaltyLion, customers can receive points for various actions they make with your brand, such as purchases, web visits, and likes on social media. 

And display the customer rewards in your own custom dashboard:

The platform will also pair you with a success manager to provide you with advice and help you grow.

Best For:   Loyalty Lion has produced amazing results for brands in the health, wellness, beauty and fashion industries. However, if you’re not generationg much revenue yet, it will likely be better to go with another option.

  • Easy-to-use UI to create a loyalty program that reflects the look and feel of your brand
  • Go beyond rewards — encourage referrals on social media and email
  • Onboarding advice to help you set up the platform
  • Assign loyalty tiers for your best customers
  • Reward subscriptions via ReCharge payments
  • Analytics that identify who your most loyal customers and which ones you need to win back


LoyaltyLion comes with a generous 14-day free plan, where you can host unlimited customers and includes 800 orders per month. Once the free trial is over, the membership starts at $159/month.


Smile is currently the most popular option when it comes to loyalty rewards programs for Shopify stores. So far, it’s been used by more than 30,000 stores and serves over 50 million members.

The platform makes it possible to create various types of rewards systems, such as loyalty points, VIP tiers, and referral programs. Its’ editor makes it easy to customize your loyalty program and build something unique without the need for a developer.

Best For:   Smile is great for any online brand that’s looking for more customization when building their loyalty program. Its easy-to-use interface makes it possioble to launch beautiful programs in just a few clicks, combining ease-of-use and robust feature set.


  • On-site reminders that encourage visitors to sign up when they’re most receptive
  • Responsive programs that look good on any device
  • Access to hundreds of resources to set you up for success
  • Detailed reports on interactions members have with your program
  • Create a sense of urgency with “expiring points” campaigns
  • Save abandoned carts with point reminders
  • Integrates with some of the best tools in the market, such as Klaviyo, Omnisend, and Mailchimp


Smile starts at $49 a month with their Growth plan at $199/month (ideal for mid-sized businesses), and the Pro Plan at $599/month for companies approaching scale.


Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals (formerly Swell rewards) is a loyalty tool that was acquired by Yotpo back in 2018. It comes with everything your store needs to engage customers and boost retention.

One feature that makes it stand out is its integration (and now ownership, as they recently acquired them) with SMSBump, one of the most prevalent SMS marketing tools in the Shopify app ecosystem.

Best For:   Brands that want to be able to maximize their engagement with multi-channel marketing. You can reach customers over email, SMS, social media, and more. If you’re looking for fraud protection as well, Swell Rewards makes sure that all customer data gets protected from misuse.


  • Ability to run multiple campaigns simultaneously
  • Built-in email capture
  • Integrations with SMSBump
  • Granular campaign settings to tailor your loyalty program based on your goals
  • Multiple on-site engagement options
  • n-house strategist to help you design the best custom loyalty program


Swell Rewards comes with a free plan for companies with below 100 orders a month. Once you surpass 100 orders, you’ll have to upgrade to their $29/month plan.


Brand Ambassador and Gift Card Platform for Both Online and Online/Retail Stores

Rise helps Shopify brands boost their customer loyalty with the power of gift cards. Customers will be able to become brand ambassadors and send branded gift cards to their loved ones via email seamlessly.

The platform doesn’t just settle with gift cards to boost brand loyalty. They also have a store credit system that deals with customer refunds and returns.

Best For:  Great for retail brands that are looking to invest in word-of-mouth marketing and manage all of their re-engagement in one platform.


  • Send store credit using automated rules with Rise’s workflow feature
  • Motivate buyers with credit, discounts, or loyalty points
  • Create marketing campaigns to re-engage old customers and target a new audience
  • One-click checkout for customers
  • Integrated with Recharge, Bold Cashier, Out Of The Sandbox, and other referral apps.


Rise comes with a free 7 day plan for users. After the free trial, it’s $16.99/month for 100 monthly store orders and $47.99/month for 400 monthly store orders.

Bold Loyalty Rewards

Loyalty Rewards is part of Bold’s large suite of tools for Ecommerce. It focuses on creating engaging loyalty points programs that customers can use in exchange for rewards. Those points can be redeemed for various offers, such as free shipping, discounts, and more.

Customers will be instantly reminded by email when they have points they can use. They can also receive bonus points for special events – such as a birthday.

Best For:  Bold Loyalty Rewards is great for brands with limited revenue that want to get a feel for loyalty marketing at a good price.


  • Bold brain feature (free) that helps track customer behavior to understand their relationship with your brand better
  • Boost referrals with easy-to-share links
  • Storefront widgets that show customers how many points they have and how close they are to a reward
  • Easy integration with other Bold tools, such as Bold Product Options, Bold Upsell, and Bold Custom Pricing


Bold starts with a free plan for brands with up to 200 members in their program. Businesses can then upgrade to the Starter plan, which includes over 500 members at $29/month. I will say that billing based on members in (or even better members actively using) the reward program is the best way to pay for the tool, in my opinion.


Well-Rounded Loyalty Tool

Lootly is a rewards program for Shopify stores that has no limitation on orders or members you can host, no matter which plan you choose. You can reward customers for leaving a product review, celebrating a birthday, creating an account, and more.

With its built-in sharing system, customers can easily share their referral discounts either on social media or email. Both the sender and recipient can be rewarded.

Best for: Companies who want to boost their brand loyalty and retention, without having to worry about how many customers they can host.


  • Unlimited orders and unlimited customers even with the free plan
  • Customize everything with no limits — emails, on-site displays, and more
  • Analytics that cover relevant details on your audience, such as order and referral history
  • Dozens of ways to reward points, from making a purchase to reading content


Lootly comes with a free 7-day trial for all of their plans. Pricing starts at $79 for its Growth Plan and can go up to $599/month for their Enterprise plan.

Next Steps

Test out a few tools, get a demo and feel out what is right for you. Strategize with your team on the best fit loyalty functions – do you want a larger social media following, more reviews, a customer portal for members to come back and check on their rewards, or perhaps the referral component is the most valuable for you. Each store is going to be different and you need to roll out the program that is right for you. 

One thing I think is most important is tracking and reporting. Loyalty programs are designed to get customers to use their loyalty points. And while that costs you money, technically, you should be thrilled to see customers using these points. Tracking loyalty points acquired and used by customers and making sure that they are spending them, incentivizes and reminds them to spend them. Don’t try to hide them from the customer and make it confusing, like some brands. Embrace the value of giving them loyalty and treat it as an investment in the relationship. One that has been proven to pay off in the long run! 

If you want to maximize your sales for your store, then you must put in a retention strategy to delight and engage your current customers. The best way to do this is to launch a loyalty program, which will not only increase your revenue, but also win back lost customers and make you stand out from the crowd.

With this list of the top loyalty rewards tools, you should be able to choose the right platform for your brand. Make sure that you also integrate your loyalty program with email marketing as well for the best results.

Special thanks to our friends at Ecommerce Tech for their insights on this topic.
The Ultimate Tech Stack For Customer-Centric Support Teams

The Ultimate Tech Stack For Customer-Centric Support Teams

Humans Of Smile: Jen On Building Culture To Support A Globally Distributed Fully Remote Team

Humans Of Smile: Jen On Building Culture To Support A Globally Distributed Fully Remote Team

You May Also Like
Share to...