If you run an ecommerce business, you may well have accepted returns as simply being part of the job. Customers are only human, so it’s understandable that they might order the wrong size, change their minds, or even find that what they received wasn’t what they expected. Whatever the reason, returns happen. And most store owners factor them into their business model.
The problem is that, in doing so, many ecommerce brands focus only on the refund itself. In other words, if a customer gets their $100 back, the assumption is that the return will only cost the business $100. However, in reality, that return might cost them significantly more.
To start with, there are shipping costs to consider, as well as staff costs, inventory costs, and sometimes even losses caused by fraud or simple mistakes. While these expenses may not seem like a big deal individually, when added together, they can take a decent chunk out of your profits month after month. This is often referred to as refund leakage.
For growing ecommerce brands, understanding where these losses come from and minimising them can be just as important a tactic as increasing sales. After all, every dollar that unnecessarily leaves your business is a dollar that could have stayed on your P&L.
If this is something you’ve never previously considered, keep on reading as we take a closer look at why returns are often far more expensive for ecommerce brands than they appear.
Most people think about returns in very simple terms. A customer buys a product, returns it, and receives a refund. End of story. Unfortunately, that’s not really how it works from a financial perspective.
That’s because every return sets off a chain of events within your business that has an associated cost. For instance, someone has to process the return request. Then the item has to be shipped back, received, inspected, and assessed. After that, inventory records need to be updated, and customer support may need to answer questions throughout the process.
Then there’s the product itself. Sometimes returned items arrive damaged, opened, or in a condition that prevents them from being sold as new. In some cases, they can’t be sold again at all and therefore become dead stock.
For this reason, many online retailers are investing in returns management software because the more visibility you have into your returns process, the easier it becomes to identify where your costs come from and where opportunities exist to reduce your return and refund losses.
Refund leakage sounds like a technical accounting term. But it’s actually a straightforward concept. Put simply, it’s money that leaves your business when it shouldn’t.
Sometimes that happens because of human error. However, other times it’s due to poor processes, weak controls, or gaps in your returns workflow. For example, a customer may accidentally receive a duplicate refund, or a team member might process the wrong amount. In some instances, a return could even be approved before the product has actually arrived back at the warehouse.
These situations don’t usually happen because somebody is being careless or incompetent. It’s usually because most ecommerce teams are busy and dealing with large volumes of orders every day.
That said, the challenge for businesses is that small mistakes can quickly become expensive when repeated hundreds of times throughout the year. To cover these losses, many business owners focus heavily on sales growth, which isn’t inherently a bad thing. But they should be paying closer attention to where money is leaking from their business.
One of the biggest reasons returns become expensive is that many of the associated costs aren’t immediately visible. Sure, the refund amount is easy to see. But the extra expenses surrounding that refund are often much harder to track.
Shipping is a good example. Mainly because if your business offers free shipping and free returns, then you’re potentially paying for two separate freight journeys without generating any revenue from the transaction.
In addition, labour is often another expense that gets missed. Every return requires someone to review the request, process the paperwork, inspect the item, and update inventory systems. Moreover, the larger your business becomes, the more labour those tasks require.
At the same time, marketing costs can also take a hit. Just imagine spending money on paid advertising to acquire a customer. Only for them to return their purchase a week later. While the advertising cost remains, the profit from the sale has disappeared.
Even those businesses with the strongest processes in place can experience refund errors. After all, people make mistakes. That said, cause and effect do play a part because if your team is manually handling large numbers of returns, there will always be opportunities for something to slip through the cracks.
Over time, small operational issues can create a steady stream of lost revenue that slowly erodes profitability. Even with strong ecommerce refund management systems, businesses can still struggle to identify these problems if they don’t conduct regular audits. By the time they discover them, the losses may have been accumulating for months.
Unfortunately, as most ecommerce brands will tell you, not every customer refund request is genuine.
Thankfully, the overwhelming majority of customers are honest. But refund fraud in online stores has become a growing concern for retailers across many industries. Not least, because some customers know exactly how to exploit generous return policies.
For example, they may claim an item never arrived even though tracking shows it was delivered. Others may return a different product. Send back damaged goods. Or attempt to receive a refund without returning anything at all.
There’s also the issue of “wardrobing”. This occurs when someone purchases an item, uses it for a short period, and then returns it for a refund. Fashion retailers, electronics brands, and outdoor equipment suppliers often encounter this type of behaviour. The financial impact of return fraud isn’t always obvious at first. However, it does add up if it occurs repeatedly throughout the year.
Here are some steps you can take to protect yourself from refund fraud.
One of the simplest ways to reduce refund fraud is to ensure products are physically received and inspected before a refund is approved. While customers understandably want their money back quickly, issuing refunds before verifying returned goods creates unnecessary risk.
Having a structured returns process in place helps you to confirm that the correct item has been returned. It also verifies that it matches the original order and meets the conditions outlined in your returns policy. Here’s how to do that:
Shipping and tracking information can provide valuable evidence when disputes arise. For instance, if a customer claims a parcel never arrived, delivery confirmations, GPS tracking data, and proof-of-delivery photos can often help clarify that it did.
Similarly, maintaining accurate records also makes it easier to identify recurring issues and spot patterns that may indicate fraudulent behaviour.
Most customers rarely return products unless they deem it absolutely necessary. However, some individuals may repeatedly place large orders, and then return unusually high percentages of purchases. Or frequently dispute transactions.
By monitoring return rates at a customer level, ecommerce brands can identify potentially risky behaviour earlier. This doesn’t mean treating every customer with suspicion. But rather recognising patterns that fall outside most people’s normal purchasing behaviour.
Creating a well-written returns policy benefits both customers and retailers. That’s because customers know exactly what to expect, while staff have clear guidelines to follow when processing requests.
Any policy you develop should outline aspects such as return timeframes, product condition requirements, refund methods, and any applicable exclusions. The more consistent you are in your processes, the better, because it reduces confusion. It also helps prevent situations where exceptions create loopholes that can be exploited.
Many ecommerce businesses spend enormous amounts of time focusing on customer acquisition, conversion rate optimisation, and increasing average order value. While these areas are important, improving profitability isn’t necessarily always about generating more revenue. Instead, in many cases, it’s about protecting the revenue you’ve already earned.
When refund leakage goes unchecked, businesses can unknowingly lose thousands of dollars each year through operational inefficiencies, duplicate refunds, unnecessary return costs, inventory write-offs, and fraudulent claims. Individually, these losses may seem minor. But collectively, they can have a meaningful impact on profit margins.
The brands that manage returns most effectively are often the ones that treat returns as a business process that deserves the same level of attention as marketing, fulfilment, and customer service. By improving visibility into your returns workflow, strengthening controls, and identifying areas where money is leaking from the business, you can create a healthier and more profitable operation.
Ultimately, while returns may always be part of ecommerce, refund leakage doesn’t have to be.
EcomBalance is a monthly bookkeeping service specialized for eCommerce companies selling on Amazon, Shopify, eBay, Etsy, WooCommerce, & other eCommerce channels.
We take monthly bookkeeping off your plate and deliver you your financial statements by the 15th or 20th of each month.
You’ll have your Profit and Loss Statement, Balance Sheet, and Cash Flow Statement ready for analysis each month so you and your business partners can make better business decisions.
Interested in learning more? Schedule a call with our CEO, Nathan Hirsch.
And here’s some free resources:
Huge thanks to Refundid for collaborating on this post!
